Video records

Thanks to vaikhAnasa scholars

• Prof ViShNu bhaTTAchAryulu for his work Agama-vimarshaH, and
• Matapalli brahmAchAryulu for sending me utpatty-asambhavAdhikaraNa of shrInivAsa-makhin’s bhAShya

Topics -

00:00 - Intro 00:55 - Chakkilam venkaTesh’s lies 04:50 - Prof ViShNu bhaTTAchAryulu of CSU Tiurpati, Agama advisor to TTD temple 05:59 - Chakkilam venkaTesh’s lies - recap 06:40 - Sources used 08:44 - viShNu-supremacy in vaikhAnasa darshana (refers to Agama-vimarsha by viShNu-bhaTTa, dasha-vidha-hetu-nirUpaNa by shrInivAsa makhI) 12:04 - Meaning of “nirguNa” in vaikhAnasa doctrine differs from shAnkara imagination (uttama-brahma-vidyA-sAra of sundararAja, vaikhAnasa-vijaya, shrInivAsa-yajvan’s bhAShya on pAramAtmikopaniShat, nRsiMha-vAjapeyi on vaikhAnasa dharmasUtra, shrInivAsa makhI’s gRhya-sUtra commentary) 24:35 - chAtur-vyUha concept in dasha-vidha-hetu-nirUpaNa by shrInivAsa makhI 28:00 - jIvan-mukti not moxa as per vaikhAnasa-s. Endorsement of vaikuNTha and 3 other loka-s. (refers to Agama-vimarsha by viShNu-bhaTTa, brahma-sUtra-shrI-vishiShTAdvaita-bhAShya by shrInivAsa-makhI) 31:30 - vishiShTAdvaita is the philosophy of vaikhAnasa-s. 33:55 - Chakkilam venkaTesh’s lies about rAmAnuja, vishiShTAdvaita, pAncharAtra. 35:55 - vaikhAnasa-brahma-sUtra-bhAShya’s utpatty-asambhavAdhikaraNa defends pAncharAtra and 4-vyUha conception. 39:15 - vaikhAnasa’s greatness beyond pAncharAtra 40:15 - Conclusion, and a question - Is Chakkilam Venkatesh, who lies and fakes so much, qualified to call himself vedAntAchArya and teach 6-darshanas?

Appendix

Original Chakkilam venkaTesh’s video - vaikhAnasa lies - TW On rAmAnuja and vishiShTAdvaita TW

Fraudulent quotes from brahmasUtra-s, viShNu-purANa (VYT) and mahAbhArata (VYT).

Correct understanding of vyAsa on pAncharAtra - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gS-xk9qiPo4&t=515s

00:00 - Intro 00:50 - mAnasataraMgiNI 01:19 - https://x.com/blog_supplement/status/1991004360059314443
03:00 - https://x.com/blog_supplement/status/1990675647534883001 04:30 - Other info about blog_supplement 05:05 - Vedic origins of vaiShNavism (pAncharAtra & vaikhAnasa ) - https://manasataramgini.wordpress.com/2020/01/02/the-roots-of-vai%E1%B9%A3%E1%B9%87avam-a-view-from-the-numerology-of-vedic-texts/ 06:40 - Conclusion

Contrast with chakkilam venkatesh - Fraudulent quotes from brahmasUtra-s, viShNu-purANa (VYT) and mahAbhArata (VYT). VYT chakkilam venkaTesh - many lies about vaikhAnasa-s (also pAncharAtra, vishiShTAdvaita, rAmAnuja)

Original video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRVweo9_0zY

00:00 - Intro 01:00 - pUrva-paxa 02:20 - overriding rUDhi meaning with etymology vs case of “mahAdeva” in vAlmIki rAmAyaNa 04:14 - cause - hatred towards vaiShNavism 05:15 - interpreting Tu Cheez Badi Hai Mast Mast (Mohra) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fT4vP4PnLxg as referring to nirguNa brahman 07:20 - kRShNa and shankara on anya-devatA adoration 09:30 - gaNAnAm tvA gaNapatim refers to brahmaNas-pati as per sAyaNa. 11:05 - cause for twisted thought 12:20 - multiplicity of devatAs - polytheism is superior to monotheism under advaitin garb.

Original video - https://youtu.be/FlJgs7EZQZk?t=391

00:00 - Intro 01:14 - Chakkilam venkatesh’s claims 03:26 - What nRsiMha-tapanIyopaniShad actually says, fluidity of divine forms not persons. 07:40 - Grammatical analysis - mAdhva interpretation (rudra meditating on nRsiMha) 10:20 - viShNu in raudra form, laxmI in umA form 13:30 - summary 14:40 - correspondances with nArAyaNa-sUktam and pancha-brahma mantras. 15:50 - What shAnkara-bhAShya actually says

Original video - https://youtu.be/UwavQTKrOTs?t=1327

00:00 Intro 02:08 Fabricates 2 pAncharAtra sUtras 03:06 Fabricates viShNu purANa verse (gramatically invalid) 05:00 “vaikuNTha” not used by rAmANuja in gItA or shrI bhAShyas 06:40 shankara on vaikuNTha 10:30 Conclusion

I emphasize that my video has been misidentified as infringing, and am willing to possibly defend the action brought against me by the copyright holder. So I resubmit my counter notification.

My video contains short clips and screenshots from Chakkilam Venkatesh’s original video (https://youtu.be/UwavQTKrOTs?t=1327) pointing out the false quotations from well known Hindu texts, with original comments and further reference to authoritative texts. As such, this is covered under “fair use” or “fair dealing” under Section 52 of the Copyright Act, 1957 (Using excerpts for criticism or review purposes).

Chakkilam Venkatesh’s misuse of copyright law to silence critics who point out his lies should be punished. My video should be reinstated.

Original video references - youtu.be/CRVweo9_0zY?t=691 - chakkilam venkatesh fabricates non-existent shloka (again gramatically incorrect) from vyAsa’s mahAbhArata

misquotes “veda vyAsa” brahma sUtra here too - https://youtu.be/CRVweo9_0zY?t=611 Repeats here - https://youtu.be/CRVweo9_0zY?t=1033

https://youtu.be/CRVweo9_0zY?t=2666 compares H sects to Hitler, ISIS islamic state, pAkistan etc..

Censorship - Comment highlighting the fabrication (seen in the video) was rapidly deleted.

00:00 - Intro 01:00 - fabricates vedavyAsa brahma-sUtras regarding pAncharAtra 01:90 - mahAbhArata/ harivaMsha shloka forgery 03:00 - conclusion 05:30 - Invitation for correction.

Original video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QLTkFroOLeI

00:00 - Intro 04:03 - mobility along archir-Adi-mArga of bhagavad-gItA, multiplicity of jIvas 09:48 - jIva-brahma difference according to BG. 12:48 - shankara on vAsudeva’s sthAna 16:55 - conclusion

venkatesh’s erroneous vid - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwavQTKrOTs&t=331s

00:00 - Intro 00:45 - Quoting verbatim 2 fake sUtras 04:26 - pAncharAtra in mahabhArata, not in any exterior place. 07:40 - Objective scholars on authenticity and antiquity 10:50 - Conclusion

venkatesh’s vid - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXxERXlDh7s

louder version of this vid - https://youtu.be/rucIjElq3mM

00:00 - Intro 01:35 - sarvagata, all pervading 04:30 - Look up dictionary 07:05 - Alleged pAncharAtra-basis of rAmAnuja 09:50 - sthANu 12:40 - conclusion

Link to original video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EQFHrenEpg .

Volume low - may need headphones.

00:00 - Intro 01:30 - 2 words 2 entities - where’s non-duality? 05:00 - jIva-s in everything with name and form. everything pervaded by jIvas as well. 11:48 - conclusion.