0241 Verse 299

Original

दिदृक्षाद्यानुकूल्येन प्रधानं संप्रवर्त्तते ।
विचित्ररचनाभेदे कथं वाऽचेतनात्मकम् ॥ २९९ ॥

didṛkṣādyānukūlyena pradhānaṃ saṃpravarttate |
vicitraracanābhede kathaṃ vā’cetanātmakam || 299 ||

If primordial matter operates towards bringing about the diversified creation, in accordance with the (spirit’s) ‘desire to see’ and the rest,—then how can it be insentient?—(299)

Kamalaśīla

Then again, if Primordial Matter knew of the Spirit’s ‘desire to see’ etc,—then it might be resonable to regard its activity to be for the sake of the Spirit, and to be in accordance with his ‘desire to see’ etc.;—as a matter of fact, however, the said Matter is itself insentient,—even when in contact with the Sentient Spirit;—it cannot then be right to regard its activity as brought about as by the contact of the Lame and the Blind. Because even though the Blind man does not see the road, yet he knows of the Lame man’s desire, because he is himself sentient. Primordial Matter however cannot know the Spirit’s ‘desire to see’ etc., because being insentient by its very nature, it is unconscious.—Nor is it possible for these two—Spirit and Primordial Matter—to be related like the Lame and the Blind,—as there can be no mutual benefit in their case.—(299)